| Zuppa San Francisco, CA | Oak Creek Brewery & Grill Sedona, AZ | Italiano's Humble, TX |
| Pirrone's Pizza Florissant, MO | Sylvia's Pizza Raleigh, NC | Rare Earth Coffee and Wine Bar Scottsdale, AZ |
| La Grande Orange Grocery and Pizzeria Phoenix, AZ | Pizzeria Bianco Phoenix, AZ | Leaning Tower of Pizza Minneapolis, MN |
| Latrán Pizza Parlour Český Krumlov, Bohemia | The Nines South Hill, NY | Mason Jar Mahwah, NJ |
| Brick's Pizza Wyckoff, NJ | Pizza Perfect Nashville, TN | 3 Tomatoes & A Mozzarella Phoenix, AZ |